Introduction
The challenge from beyond is a round-robin (collaboration) 1935 horror short story written by Howard Phillips Lovecraft, Frank Belknap Long, Robert E. Howard, C. L. Moore, and Abraham Merritt. It was published in Fantasy Magazine and is part of the Cthulhu Mythos. Howard wrote one chapter of this story. It was published in September 1935 in Fantasy Magazine, a fan publication.
This unique literary experiment, The Challenge From Beyond, comprises two distinct parts created by an ensemble of science fiction and fantasy writers, each contributing to a narrative that bridges the realms of the mundane and the extraordinary. Here’s a detailed summary of each author’s contribution to the fantasy version, followed by a list of characters and their roles.
C. L. Moore
George Campbell, relishing his vacation in the Canadian woods, discovers a peculiar, ancient crystal cube after being awoken by a nocturnal disturbance. This cube, smooth and perfectly formed despite its evident antiquity, captivates Campbell with its inscrutable presence and mysterious, cuneiform-like inscriptions. Intrigued and unsettled, Campbell’s initial examination reveals little about the cube’s origin or purpose, setting the stage for a journey beyond the bounds of his understanding.
A. Merritt
As Campbell investigates the cube further, it begins to emit a faint, mesmerizing light, accompanied by ethereal sounds reminiscent of distant music. This phenomenon intensifies his curiosity and unease, drawing him into an inexplicable, almost hypnotic engagement with the object. The cube’s glowing and the strange music hint at an otherworldly essence, suggesting that the artifact is more than merely a relic of the past.
H.P. Lovecraft
Campbell’s encounter with the cube transcends the physical as he experiences a disorienting journey across cosmic distances, ultimately finding himself disembodied in a realm far removed from human understanding. This segment plunges Campbell into a nightmarish introspection, where he grapples with the reality of his situation and the horrifying possibility that he has become entangled in an ancient, extraterrestrial scheme beyond his comprehension.
Robert E. Howard
Campbell, now trapped in the body of an alien creature on a distant world, embraces his new, monstrous form with a sense of liberation and power. Determined to carve out a dominion for himself in this unfamiliar reality, he employs his human cunning in a brutal struggle for survival and supremacy. This act of defiance against his circumstances demonstrates Campbell’s refusal to be a victim of fate, showcasing a primal, almost barbaric resolve.
Frank Belknap Long
Meanwhile, on Earth, the body of George Campbell, inhabited by the mind of an alien creature, undergoes a transformation reflecting its new, non-human consciousness. This metamorphosis culminates in a grim tableau that juxtaposes the savagery of nature with the existential horror of a being torn from its world and thrust into an alien existence. The narrative closes with a profound meditation on identity, belonging, and the inherent violence of life, both on Earth and across the cosmos.
Characters and their roles
- George Campbell: A university professor on vacation, whose curiosity leads him to a life-altering encounter with an ancient, alien artifact.
- The Alien (Inhabiting Campbell’s Body): An entity from a distant world, thrust into Campbell’s body, struggling with its new, bestial form on Earth.
- Yukth: The supreme lord of science on the alien planet Yekub, who becomes a victim of Campbell’s desperate bid for freedom and power.
- Tothe: The alien creature whose body George Campbell inhabits on the planet Yekub, enabling Campbell’s struggle for dominance in an alien society.
- The Worm-Priest: A guardian of the alien deity, killed by Campbell in his quest to seize control of Yekub.
- The Red God of Yekub: A powerful entity revered by the inhabitants of Yekub, symbolizing Campbell’s ultimate conquest and transformation.
Published in:
- FANTASY MAGAZINE Volume 5 Number 4, Conrad H. Ruppert, September 1935
- BEYOND THE WALL OF SLEEP, Arkham House, 1943
- THE CHALLENGE FROM BEYOND, Fantasy Amateur Press Association, 1954
- FANTASTIC SCIENCE FICTION STORIES VOLUME 9 NUMBER 5, Ziff-Davis Publishing Company, May 1960
- HORRORS UNKNOWN, Walker & Company, June 1971
- HORRORS UNKNOWN, The Ryerson Press (Canada), June 1971
- HORRORS UNKNOWN, Kaye & Ward (UK), June 1972
- UNIVERS 01, J’ai Lu, May 1975 (French)
- HORRORS UNKNOWN, Berkley, February 1976
- SFIDA DALL’INFINITO, Fanucci Editore, September 1976 (Italian)
- THE ILLUSTRATED CHALLENGE FROM BEYOND, Necronomicon Press, 1978
- 真ク・リトル・リトル神話大系 2 (SHINKU RITORU RITORU SHINWA TAIKEI #2) (TALES OF THE CTHULHU MYTHOS AT LAST #2), Kokusho Kankohkai, August 1982 (Japanese)
- POLARIS, Fanucci Editore, January 1989 (Italian)
- THE CHALLENGE FROM BEYOND, Necronomicon Press, 1st, 1990
- H. P. LOVECRAFT. TUTTI I RACCONTI. 1931-1936, Arnoldo Mondadori Editore, June 1992 (Italian)
- TUTTI I ROMANZI E I RACCONTI. L’INCUBO – TUTTE LE STORIE DELL’ORRORE PURO, Newton Compton Editori, October 1993 (Italian)
- DAS GROSSE LESEBUCH DER FANTASY, Wilhelm Goldmann Verlag, November 1995 (German)
- THE CHALLENGE FROM BEYOND, Necronomicon Press, 2nd, 1997
- LOS DILETANTES DE LOVECRAFT 2, Club Los Diletantes de Lovecraft, October 1997 (Spanish)
- H. P. LOVECRAFT. TUTTI I RACCONTI. 1931-1936, Arnoldo Mondadori Editore, January 1998 (Italian)
- DER LOVECRAFT-ZIRKEL, Blitz-Verlag, 2000 (German)
- NAMELESS CULTS, Chaosium, December 2001
- THE ROAD TO VELITRIUM #49, James Van Hise, February 2003 [Distributed in REHupa #179]
- LOVECRAFT: LE STORIE DELL’ORRORE PURO, Newton Compton Editori, September 2004 (Italian)
- SEEKERS OF DREAM, Cold Spring Press, August 2005
- SWORD & FANTASY #4, James Van Hise, October 2005
- THE CROSS PLAINSMAN, Frank Coffman, December 2005 [Distributed in REHupa #196]
- DER LOVECRAFT-ZIRKEL, Festa Verlag, February 2006 (German)
- BEYOND THE BLACK RIVER, Wildside Press, September 2007
- 新編 真ク・リトル・リトル神話大系〔2〕(SHINPEN MA KU RITORU RITORU SHINWA TAIKEI〔2 〕(TALES OF THE CTHULHU MYTHOS 2), Kokusho Kankohkai, November 2007 (Japanese)
- H. P. LOVECRAFT. TUTTI I RACCONTI. 1931-1936, Arnoldo Mondadori Editore, May 2008 (Italian)
- PEOPLE OF THE DARK: THE WEIRD WORKS OF ROBERT E. HOWARD VOLUME 2, Audio Realms, June 2008 (audio)
- BEYOND THE BLACK RIVER, Cosmos Books, July 2008
- ADVENTURES IN SCIENCE FANTASY, REH Foundation Press, May 2012
- WEIRD TALES: 101 WEIRD, STRANGE, AND SUPERNATURAL STORIES VOLUME 1, Civitas Media, May 2012
- KRÓLESTWO CIENI I INNE OPOWIADANIA Z MITOLOGII CTHULHU, Agharta, January 2013 (Polish, REH fragment only)
- WEIRD TALES: 101 WEIRD, STRANGE, AND SUPERNATURAL STORIES VOLUME 1, Civitas Media, April 2013
- LOVECRAFTIN LÄHTEILLÄ, Jalava, 2013 (Finnish)
- THE CHALLENGE FROM BEYOND, Lance Thingmaker, October 2014
- CHILLING HORROR SHORT STORIES, Flame Tree Publishing, September 2015
- THE SHADOW KINGDOM AND OTHER WEIRD TALES, Ulwencreutz Media, October 2015
- TALES OF CTHULHU, Perennial Press, November 2015
- THOSE DREADFUL ELTDOWN SHARDS, H. Harksen Productions, August 2016
- THE SECOND CTHULHU MYTHOS MEGAPACK, Wildside Press, October 2016
- TALES OF CTHULHU, Jovian Press, December 2016
- THE CHALLENGE FROM BEYOND DRAFTS, Robert E. Howard Foundation, April 2020 (Complete story and REH Drafts A, B, and C)
- THE CTHULHU STORIES OF ROBERT E. HOWARD, WordFire Press, September 2020
- ADVENTURES IN SCIENCE FANTASY, Ultimate Edition REH Foundation Press, October 2024
More information, links, etc.:
- Lovecraft Fandom, The Challenge from Beyond