Textual identity is not textual authority. “Catalogue primary/default” selects the default catalogue representation; it does not mean that this wording is automatically Howard’s most authoritative text.
Characters in this exact text
AlexanderAlexander — Breckinridge Elkins's muleOn Pagefirst: First Cuts: Rough Trails 4, p. 29Mister O'ToolBat O'Tool — visiting boxer from New YorkMentionedfirst: First Cuts: Rough Trails 4, p. 29my younger brother BillBill Elkins — Breckinridge's brother; not his father Roarin' Bill ElkinsMentionedfirst: First Cuts: Rough Trails 4, p. 42Breckinridge Elkins / IBreckinridge ElkinsOn Pagefirst: First Cuts: Rough Trails 4, p. 29Cap'n KiddCap'n Kidd — historical pirate mentioned as the stallion's namesakeMentionedfirst: First Cuts: Rough Trails 4, p. 33Cap'n KiddCap’n Kidd — Breckinridge Elkins's horseOn Pagefirst: First Cuts: Rough Trails 4, p. 32Ellen ReynoldsEllen Reynolds — woman courted by Breckinridge and Jim Braxton in Guns of the MountainsMentionedfirst: First Cuts: Rough Trails 4, p. 43Glory McGraw / Miss McGrawGlory McGraw — Bear Creek woman loved by Breckinridge; daughter of Old Man McGrawOn Pagefirst: First Cuts: Rough Trails 4, p. 29my brother JohnJohn Elkins — Breckinridge's brotherMentionedfirst: First Cuts: Rough Trails 4, p. 35RedRed — large red-headed member of Wild Bill Donovan's partyOn Pagefirst: First Cuts: Rough Trails 4, p. 41papRoarin' Bill Elkins — Breckinridge's fatherMentionedfirst: First Cuts: Rough Trails 4, p. 29SmokySmoky — member of Wild Bill Donovan's party who deals the rigged card gameOn Pagefirst: First Cuts: Rough Trails 4, p. 40Mister WilkinsonSnake River Wilkinson — Wild River cowpuncher and Glory McGraw's would-be suitor; called Mr. Richardson in Draft 1Mentionedfirst: First Cuts: Rough Trails 4, p. 31Wild Bill Donovan / Donovan / BillWild Bill Donovan — cowpuncher/outlaw-like leader pursuing Cap'n Kidd with five menOn Pagefirst: First Cuts: Rough Trails 4, p. 32
Surviving manuscript evidence
The records below describe surviving physical typescripts, carbons, manuscript material and documentary catalogue evidence for this exact textual state. TSS numbers identify physical catalogue units; they are not story or draft IDs.
Draft 1 — separately paginated Howard Chapter .3. typescriptHoward typescript
Extent15 pagesCompletenessPossibly incomplete
Physical extent: 15-page typescript; page 16 may or may not be missing
TSS: 61935–61944, 51740–51747
Howard typescript marked “Chapter .3.” with pagination restarting at page 1. First Cuts treats the restarted pagination as evidence that this was prepared separately rather than as part of a continuous novel manuscript.
Additional documentary notes
- Separate Pagination: Although marked Chapter .3., pagination restarts from page 1. First Cuts interprets this as evidence of a separately prepared state rather than a continuous novel manuscript. (witness level)
- Authorial Chapter Heading: The witness is marked “Chapter .3.”. First Cuts describes the typescript as untitled apart from this chapter designation. (manuscript page 1)
- Possible Missing Final Page: First Cuts says page 16 may or may not be missing; the surviving 15-page state may nevertheless be complete. (end of witness) · Possible
- Catalogue Unit Count Mismatch: First Cuts describes a 15-page witness but cites eighteen TSS catalogue numbers: 61935–61944 and 51740–51747. No one-to-one page/TSS mapping is inferred. (whole witness)
- Later Novel Expansion: First Cuts notes that a long sentence was added when this material was later incorporated into A Gent from Bear Creek. (textual-state comparison)
Source: First Cuts: Breckinridge Elkins — Rough Trails 4, Meet Cap'n Kidd, Editorial Notes p. 27; Draft 1 pp. 29–43

