Exact textual stateDraft

The Vale of Lost Women (draft 1)

StateDraft 1Surviving witnesses1TSS catalogue units17
Textual identity is not textual authority. “Catalogue primary/default” selects the default catalogue representation; it does not mean that this wording is automatically Howard’s most authoritative text.

Catalogue facts

WrittenFebruary 1933

Introduction

The Vale of Lost Women is a fantasy short story by Robert E. Howard and one of his original stories featuring Conan the Cimmerian. It was not published during his lifetime. The Magazine of Horror first published the story in its Spring, 1967 issue, and it was later republished that same year in Conan of Cimmeria (Lancer Books, 1967). Both printings featured the same edited version of the tale. The following is a detailed analysis and summary of the first known draft of the story. As far as I know it has never been published. The second draft was used when Wandering Star published the story.

Summary spoilers

The first draft of The Vale of Lost Women begins with a harrowing scene. Sareeta, an Ophirean noblewoman, lies in a stupor in the hut of the Bakalah tribe after witnessing the ritual torture and murder of her younger brother, Theteles. Her spirit is broken, but her desire for vengeance slowly coalesces as she learns of the arrival of a powerful white stranger in the village—Conan, the Cimmerian and war chief of the Bamulas.

Conan has arrived at the invitation of Bajujh, the grotesque, toad-like king of the Bakalahs, to discuss a joint raid against the neighboring Jihiji tribe. Despite outward civility, Conan distrusts Bajujh and stations his men outside his hut. Sareeta, seeing a chance at salvation, sneaks into Conan’s hut and pleads for vengeance, offering herself as payment if he kills Bajujh. Conan is initially offended at her assumption he must be bribed, but after hearing her tale and seeing her humiliation, he agrees—not for lust, but out of disgust that a white woman is held captive by a black king.

The next night, during a feast, Conan gives a signal and his Bamulas slaughter the Bakalahs in a surprise massacre. Sareeta, in a frenzy of horror, flees the carnage on horseback and escapes into the wilderness. She ends up in a mysterious valley spoken of in whispers among the natives—a place of lost women transformed into flowers by ancient gods. There she is met by silent, beautiful brown-skinned women who paralyze her with a kiss and lay her on a stone altar.

A horrific, otherworldly being—a massive bat-winged entity—descends from the stars, summoned by the women. Just as it is about to claim her, Conan bursts into the glade, wounds the beast in a fierce struggle, and drives it away. When Sareeta admits she tried to escape their bargain, Conan surprises her by releasing her from it, calling their pact dishonorable. Instead, he offers to escort her back to civilization, refusing to take her by force.

Compared with Draft 2 of The Vale of Lost Women, Draft 1 uses the name Sareeta for the female protagonist; the later draft changes her name to Livia. The second draft also revises phrasing and dialogue, expands some descriptive and psychological passages, and alters a number of individual lines.

Among the more visible changes are revisions to Conan's dialogue and to the heroine's reflections on her situation, together with changes in the description of the supernatural women and the creature in the Vale.

Comparing the first and second draft

Both drafts of The Vale of Lost Women tell the story of a white woman captured by a black tribe in a fantasy Africa-like setting, her encounter with Conan, and her flight into a supernatural valley where she is nearly sacrificed to a monstrous godlike being. The second draft, while largely following the structure of the first, is a more polished and tightened version of the tale. This analysis identifies key differences between the two texts.

Comparison Conclusion

The second draft of The Vale of Lost Women represents Howard's attempt to elevate his prose style, deepen psychological realism, and better integrate horror and action within the tale. The core narrative remains unchanged, but Livia is given a more resonant voice, and the weird atmosphere of the valley is more vividly rendered. This refinement process shows Howard transitioning from raw pulp storytelling to more literary weird fantasy.

Surviving manuscript evidence

The records below describe surviving physical typescripts, carbons, manuscript material and documentary catalogue evidence for this exact textual state. TSS numbers identify physical catalogue units; they are not story or draft IDs.

Draft 1 — surviving Howard typescriptHoward typescript
Extent17 pagesCompletenessComplete

Physical extent: 17 pages / 17 TSS catalogue units

TSS: 90918–90920, 90922–90932, 52672–52673, 66044

Original typescript (OT).

Additional documentary notes

  • Untitled Witness: The spreadsheet records this surviving witness as untitled. (witness level)

Source: 000 TSS of REH moving towards final.xls · Complete List · Vale of Lost Women, The (d1) · TSS 90918–90920, 90922–90932, 52672–52673, 66044