Textual identity is not textual authority. “Catalogue primary/default” selects the default catalogue representation; it does not mean that this wording is automatically Howard’s most authoritative text.
Characters in this exact text
Aunt AtascosaAunt Atascosa — family correspondent who reported Bearfield’s chicken theftMentionedfirst: First Cuts: Rough Trails 2, p. 272Bearfield Buckner / Cousin BearfieldBearfield Buckner — Texas Buckner; Breckinridge’s cousinOn Pagefirst: First Cuts: Rough Trails 2, p. 271Bill SantryBill Santry — Cougar Paw man; Joan’s brother; John Elkins’ horse-trade adversaryOn Pagefirst: First Cuts: Rough Trails 2, p. 264Breckinridge ElkinsBreckinridge ElkinsOn Pagefirst: First Cuts: Rough Trails 2, p. 263Cap'n KiddCap’n Kidd — Breckinridge Elkins's horseOn Pagefirst: First Cuts: Rough Trails 2, p. 263Uncle Jeppard GrimesJeppard Grimes — Breckinridge's Uncle Jeppard; owner of the missing goldMentionedfirst: First Cuts: Rough Trails 2, p. 272JoanJoan — young woman near Cougar Paw; sister of Bill SantryOn Pagefirst: First Cuts: Rough Trails 2, p. 266Joe RichardsonJoe Richardson — man Bearfield shot/encountered during an earlier posse episodeMentionedfirst: First Cuts: Rough Trails 2, p. 272John / John ElkinsJohn Elkins — Breckinridge's brotherOn Pagefirst: First Cuts: Rough Trails 2, p. 263Jonathan MiddletonJonathan Middleton — mayor, general-store proprietor and saloon proprietor of Cougar PawOn Pagefirst: First Cuts: Rough Trails 2, p. 266Old Man KirbyOld Man Kirby — Cougar Range resident whose bull chases JoanMentionedfirst: First Cuts: Rough Trails 2, p. 265Old Man WestfallOld Man Westfall — owner of the chicken Bearfield stole as a youthMentionedfirst: First Cuts: Rough Trails 2, p. 272papRoarin' Bill Elkins — Breckinridge's fatherOn Pagefirst: First Cuts: Rough Trails 2, p. 264
Surviving manuscript evidence
The records below describe surviving physical typescripts, carbons, manuscript material and documentary catalogue evidence for this exact textual state. TSS numbers identify physical catalogue units; they are not story or draft IDs.
Draft 2 — surviving Howard carbon copyHoward carbon copy
Extent21 pagesCompletenessComplete
Physical extent: Complete 21-page carbon-copy draft
TSS: 61607–61623, 61626–61627, 93569, 93572
Complete untitled carbon-copy typescript, described by First Cuts as possibly representing the final version submitted.
Additional documentary notes
- Possible submission state: First Cuts describes this carbon copy as possibly representing the final version submitted. The claim is preserved as possible rather than certain and does not identify it with the published Action Stories text. (Draft 2 witness) · Possible
- Non Authorial Duplicate Copies: Glenn Lord created duplicate copies of pages 18 and 19. First Cuts states that the original typescript sheets are used instead; the Lord duplicates are documentary copies, not Howard revisions. (Pages 18 and 19 / TSS 61624, 61625)
- Typed Insertion: The phrase “, and he said likely he was up to the store.” was typed above the line after Breckinridge asks where to find Bill Santry. (First Cuts p. 267)
Source: First Cuts: Breckinridge Elkins — Rough Trails 2, The Riot at Cougar Paw, Editorial Notes; Draft 2 transcription pp. 263–280

