Textual identity is not textual authority. “Catalogue primary/default” selects the default catalogue representation; it does not mean that this wording is automatically Howard’s most authoritative text.
Characters in this exact text
Cousin Bill GordonBill Gordon — Bear Creek cousin whose barn, wagon and animals Breckinridge usesMentionedfirst: First Cuts: Rough Trails 2, p. 319BillBill Grimes — one of Jeppard Grimes’s sonsOn Pagefirst: First Cuts: Rough Trails 2, p. 332Breckinridge ElkinsBreckinridge ElkinsOn Pagefirst: First Cuts: Rough Trails 2, p. 317Cousin Buckner / Buckner KirbyBuckner Kirby — Kit Kirby’s father; called Old Man Kirby/Uncle Buck in Draft 1 and Cousin Buckner in later draftsMentionedfirst: First Cuts: Rough Trails 2, p. 322Cap’n KiddCap’n Kidd — Breckinridge Elkins's horseOn Pagefirst: First Cuts: Rough Trails 2, p. 317Dick GrimesDick Grimes — one of Jeppard Grimes’s sons; father of the unnamed youngest daughter who reports on Joshua; called Dick Kirby in Draft 1Mentionedfirst: First Cuts: Rough Trails 2, p. 321Dick Grimes’ youngest galDick Grimes’s youngest daughter — unnamed young Bear Creek girl; Jeppard Grimes’s granddaughter; sees Breckinridge transporting JoshuaOn Pagefirst: First Cuts: Rough Trails 2, p. 321ErathErath Grimes — one of Jeppard Grimes’s sonsOn Pagefirst: First Cuts: Rough Trails 2, p. 332Esau GrimesEsau Grimes — one of Jeppard Grimes's sons in War on Bear Creek; not permanent Esau Grimes #49On Pagefirst: First Cuts: Rough Trails 2, p. 332Harry BraxtonHarry Braxton — young man courting Kit Kirby; from the other side of Apache MountainOn Pagefirst: First Cuts: Rough Trails 2, p. 322JacobJacob Grimes — one of Jeppard Grimes’s sons; Dick Grimes’s brother; not permanent Jacob Grimes #68On Pagefirst: First Cuts: Rough Trails 2, p. 332Uncle Jeppard GrimesJeppard Grimes — Breckinridge's Uncle Jeppard; owner of the missing goldMentionedfirst: First Cuts: Rough Trails 2, p. 319JimJim Grimes — one of Jeppard Grimes’s sonsOn Pagefirst: First Cuts: Rough Trails 2, p. 332JoeJoe Grimes — one of Jeppard Grimes’s sonsOn Pagefirst: First Cuts: Rough Trails 2, p. 332Joel GarfieldJoel Garfield — Apache Mountain stillhouse keeper; called Joel Grimes/Uncle Joel in Draft 1; not automatically Joel Garfield #73On Pagefirst: First Cuts: Rough Trails 2, p. 324JoshuaJoshua — Uncle Jeppard Grimes’s favorite jackass; called Agamemenon/Agamemnon/Agermemnon/Agememnon earlier in Draft 1On Pagefirst: First Cuts: Rough Trails 2, p. 319KitKit Kirby — Buckner Kirby’s daughter; Harry Braxton’s intended brideOn Pagefirst: First Cuts: Rough Trails 2, p. 322MaKit Kirby’s mother — unnamed mother of Kit Kirby; called “Ma” by KitMentionedfirst: First Cuts: Rough Trails 2, p. 322papRoarin' Bill Elkins — Breckinridge's fatherMentionedfirst: First Cuts: Rough Trails 2, p. 317Uncle Shadrach PolkShadrach Polk — Breckinridge’s Uncle Shadrach; husband of Tascosa PolkMentionedfirst: First Cuts: Rough Trails 2, p. 317Aunt Tascosa PolkTascosa Polk — Breckinridge’s Aunt Tascosa; wife of Shadrach PolkOn Pagefirst: First Cuts: Rough Trails 2, p. 317
Surviving manuscript evidence
The records below describe surviving physical typescripts, carbons, manuscript material and documentary catalogue evidence for this exact textual state. TSS numbers identify physical catalogue units; they are not story or draft IDs.
Draft 4 — complete but badly damaged Howard typescriptHoward typescript
Extent22 pagesCompletenessComplete
Physical extent: 22 pages, complete; badly damaged
TSS: 26280–26297, 27297–27301
Untitled Howard typescript of 22 pages. First Cuts describes it as badly damaged and extremely difficult to read in places.
Additional documentary notes
- Damaged Typescript: The typescript is badly damaged. (throughout witness)
- Difficult To Read: First Cuts describes portions as extremely difficult to read. (multiple places)
- Source Page Count Catalogue Count Discrepancy: First Cuts describes 22 physical pages but cites 23 TSS catalogue numbers (26280–26297, 27297–27301). The discrepancy is preserved without assuming a duplicate or replacement sheet. (witness-level)
- Textual Relation To Published: First Cuts says Draft 4 closely resembles the final printed version, while some words and phrases differ. It remains a separate textual state from the Action Stories publication. (witness-level)
Source: First Cuts: Breckinridge Elkins — Rough Trails 2, The Apache Mountain War, Editorial Notes p. 283; transcription pp. 317–336

